Thanks everyone for your input over the past few days. I very nearly deleted Darklinks and shut it down for good.
More details later, but for now:
An awesome famous webmaster from the horror scene is helping me convert Darklinks into a less-easily-stealable format AND add a blog feed to the front page, so we'll have the best of both worlds: Updated Blog, ...and extensive link database. We'll probably also have a search engine.
We'll still have my uglyass page design though!